Open Media 100
Tax the NRIs

Be Corrupt or Perish

Many people have highlighted the stifling regulations in India. Jayant Bhandari points out that inefficient and arbitrary enforcement of regulations really makes it terrible:

Economists would argue that government rules and minimum wage laws are the biggest cause of unemployment and poverty; and that government control takes away the individual initiative to enter into voluntary contracts, restricting the growth of a sophisticated and efficient web of contacts that provides sustainable growth, and stability.

But such a lack of economic efficiency would result in places where the laws were effectively enforced. In India, as in a lot of developing countries, this has a marginal importance: in real practice there are no minimum salaries and no control by the government on the working conditions as my acquaintance now experiences.

...

In such an environment the distortions take place in a different way, and are much worse. What rules the roost is corruption and bureaucracy. It drives the decent and conscientious to the fringes of economic activity (and the best leave the country). For those who go into business, it becomes the biggest cost of operation, and a huge drag on growth. People get a corrupt mindset, and those who do not want to participate in corrupt behavior get sidelined economically.

I think many regulations in India and elsewhere are designed for corruption. The rules are designed so that they are almost impossible to follow. For bureaucrats and the "law" enforcement authorities it a license to steal. There is not even a pretense of morality in those rules and therefore people and officers do not even think twice before offering and demanding bribes.
But what really surprises and confuses me is that ordinary people grumble about having to pay the bribe but do not want to do anything to remove the unjust rules and regulations. There is an amazing lack of debate about these rules. When people do debate, they point out without a hint of irony that if police and other officers were not so corrupt then the rules would have worked. It is as if the God should have manufactured police and other officers using some special anti-corruption material. Why don't we realize that Govt. servants (or masters) come from the same pool as rest of us? How can they be more honest (statistically speaking) than the general public?
In fact, with so much noise about India being the world's largest democracy, not even in one election, national or local, were the rules an issue! It is absolutely stunning that people bring corruption, misery and poverty onto themselves for 50 years and still not realize the reasons for their lot!

Comments

Apun Ka Desh

A very good point. But in most cases ordinary citizens do not have the wherewithal to fight the masive red tape and openly practised corruption.

But, we need to do something.

http://apunkadesh.blogspot.com

Ashish Hanwadikar

Trevor,
Very true indeed! In fact, in developed countries like US, you have lots of overzealous prosecutors going after people. Lots of media attention for spicy cases is also a potentially dangerous ingredient. Also, that means rights of real victims are routinely ignored.

Trevor

The corrupt politicians of the U.S. have pursued and won in the exact same manner - by creating so many rules at so many different levels of government that we are all criminals waiting to be convicted.

You cannot live in the U.S. and do anything productive without breaking many laws, most of which you are likely to be completely unaware of. This has happened by intentional design, and yes, most people are completely ignorant of it, and go about their business completely ignorant of the fact that if they ever anger any of a plethora of authorities, they will find that all their assumptions about and trust in government are naive and misplaced.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)